Margaret Atwood, The Handmaid's Tale. pages 200-277
In "1984", "Fahrenheit 451" and "The Handmaid's Tale" all 3 protagonists represent the rebel archetype. The desire to rebel simply arises from the fact that their opinions do no coincide with those of the society's. In all three cases, the reason why the protagonists rebel is because they feel attached to the world that exists before the oppressive society that they are trapped in. But the reason why they feel attached to it varies for every protagonist.
In Winston's case, he feels attached to the world before, because of several blurry memories that he has of the world that exists before the Revolution. These memories consist of his mother, his sister, and a lingering feeling that things were not as grimy and people were not as reduced as they are under the ruling of Big Brother. It is because of this reason that he rebels against the party by committing "Thought Crime" and being with his girlfriend, Julia, despite the fact that any relationships are strictly forbidden by the party.
Similarly, Offred also rebels because she feels attached to the past just like Winston does. She is haunted by the memories of the world before,and of the things that she possessed and the freedom that she had then, which she no longer has. It is because of gaining a momentary state of freedom, that she eagerly accepts when the Commander demands to secretly meet her every evening, and to commit illegal acts such as playing Scrabble, reading magazines, and using hand creme.
Montag, though, is slightly different from these two characters. Despite the fact that he has not resided in the society that exists before books are burned, he begins to question his values when a girl named Clarisse tells him about a time when things were different, a time when firemen put out fires rather than initiated them. This opens his mind, and it connects him to the past world where books existed. It also makes him question what information books contain that make them such a "threat" and cause them to be burned immediately after being discovered by the firemen. This is one of the reasons why Montag rebels by reading books. Through such an act, he discovers that books contain valuable life lessons, that are compacted together into one manual.
Thursday, December 18, 2008
The Handmaid's Tale: Unique (Application)
Margaret Atwood, The Handmaid's Tale. pages 100-200
"Women can't add," he said jokingly.When I asked him what he meant, he said,"For them, one and one and one and one don't make four." "What do they make?" I said, expecting five or three. "Just one and one and one and one," he said. (Atwood 171)
The Commander is the character that states the quote above, while talking to with Offred. The quote is significant because it shows what the characters' beliefs are, regarding relationships. It shows that the Commander believes women, unlike men, find each man unique in such a way, that they cannot substitute them for another.
This quote was chosen because this same concept of uniqueness can be applied to "The Beacons" poem by Charles Baudelaire. In the poem, every artist is described in a very divergent way, and they are each depicted as separate units. The way this is done is through the use of various imagery and metaphors. For example, one artist's style of painting, Rembrandt's, is described in a very somber way. He is depicted in such a way, through phrases such as a "sad hospital full of murmurs." This imagery is drastically different from the imagery that is used to describe the other artists, which is why it makes the reader perceive Rembrandt's style as highly unique.
Not only are the artists described in a drastically different way literally, but they are also portrayed as different units visually. That is because in the poem, every paragraph pertains to a specific artist, and the description of their style. And two artists are never described within the same paragraph, because the author, Baudelaire, wants to create a sense of detachment, visually, through the separation of one artist per paragraph.
"Women can't add," he said jokingly.When I asked him what he meant, he said,"For them, one and one and one and one don't make four." "What do they make?" I said, expecting five or three. "Just one and one and one and one," he said. (Atwood 171)
The Commander is the character that states the quote above, while talking to with Offred. The quote is significant because it shows what the characters' beliefs are, regarding relationships. It shows that the Commander believes women, unlike men, find each man unique in such a way, that they cannot substitute them for another.
This quote was chosen because this same concept of uniqueness can be applied to "The Beacons" poem by Charles Baudelaire. In the poem, every artist is described in a very divergent way, and they are each depicted as separate units. The way this is done is through the use of various imagery and metaphors. For example, one artist's style of painting, Rembrandt's, is described in a very somber way. He is depicted in such a way, through phrases such as a "sad hospital full of murmurs." This imagery is drastically different from the imagery that is used to describe the other artists, which is why it makes the reader perceive Rembrandt's style as highly unique.
Not only are the artists described in a drastically different way literally, but they are also portrayed as different units visually. That is because in the poem, every paragraph pertains to a specific artist, and the description of their style. And two artists are never described within the same paragraph, because the author, Baudelaire, wants to create a sense of detachment, visually, through the separation of one artist per paragraph.
Tuesday, December 16, 2008
The Handmaid's tale: Ancient Greece
Margaret, Atwood. The Handmaid's Tale. pages 100-200
"They've frozen them, she said. Mine too...Any account with an F on it instead of an M. All they needed to do is push a few buttons. We're cut off." (Atwood 167)
Moira (Offred's friend) says this after the revolution in "The Handmaid's Tale" begins, when the President and the Congress are shot.
This quote was chosen because it shows the first symptoms of what the male dominating society in "The Handmaid's Tale" is doing to the females. Furthermore, the events that occur in this quote can also be related to certain events that have occurred in other cultures.
"The Handmaid's Tale" highlights how powerful men can be, and how they can have the ability to strip women of their rights, and to force them to do things that they would find unimaginable to do otherwise. Furthermore, it also shows how helpless women are when faced with a society that is entirely controlled by men.Some of the rights that the Handmaid's in the novel have taken away are: the right to read, the right to leave the household(unless shopping for groceries with another Handmaid), and the right to speak against the situation that they're trapped in.
Throughout the course of history, there have existed women from different cultures that have lacked possession of the same rights. One such group of women were the ones that resided in Ancient Greece. A commonality that lies between the two groups is illiteracy. Just like the women in "The Handmaid's Tale" are forbidden to read so that throughout the course of time they will turn illiterate, the women in Ancient Greece were not forbidden to read. Instead, they were unable to read because of not being taught how to. Furthermore, they were also unable to speak out about subjects of great importance like Philosophy, because their opinions were considered invalid. This is similar to the way that women in" The Handmaid's Tale" are not allowed to express any unorthodox beliefs. In addition to that, in Ancient Greece, women were also in charge of domestic chores such as cooking, which meant that they were rarely able to leave the home. In "The Handmaid's Tale" the Handmaid's are also unable to leave the household unless they are send out to shop for certain food items.
"They've frozen them, she said. Mine too...Any account with an F on it instead of an M. All they needed to do is push a few buttons. We're cut off." (Atwood 167)
Moira (Offred's friend) says this after the revolution in "The Handmaid's Tale" begins, when the President and the Congress are shot.
This quote was chosen because it shows the first symptoms of what the male dominating society in "The Handmaid's Tale" is doing to the females. Furthermore, the events that occur in this quote can also be related to certain events that have occurred in other cultures.
"The Handmaid's Tale" highlights how powerful men can be, and how they can have the ability to strip women of their rights, and to force them to do things that they would find unimaginable to do otherwise. Furthermore, it also shows how helpless women are when faced with a society that is entirely controlled by men.Some of the rights that the Handmaid's in the novel have taken away are: the right to read, the right to leave the household(unless shopping for groceries with another Handmaid), and the right to speak against the situation that they're trapped in.
Throughout the course of history, there have existed women from different cultures that have lacked possession of the same rights. One such group of women were the ones that resided in Ancient Greece. A commonality that lies between the two groups is illiteracy. Just like the women in "The Handmaid's Tale" are forbidden to read so that throughout the course of time they will turn illiterate, the women in Ancient Greece were not forbidden to read. Instead, they were unable to read because of not being taught how to. Furthermore, they were also unable to speak out about subjects of great importance like Philosophy, because their opinions were considered invalid. This is similar to the way that women in" The Handmaid's Tale" are not allowed to express any unorthodox beliefs. In addition to that, in Ancient Greece, women were also in charge of domestic chores such as cooking, which meant that they were rarely able to leave the home. In "The Handmaid's Tale" the Handmaid's are also unable to leave the household unless they are send out to shop for certain food items.
Monday, December 15, 2008
The Handmaid's tale, Fahrenheit 451, and 1984: Connections part 1
Margaret Atwood, The Handmaid's Tale. pages 100-200
One commonality that exists between the three novels, is a law that gets broken by each protagonist.
In "1984," the law that Winston breaks is referred to as "Thought Crime." The way that "Thought Crime," is committed, is when a citizen of Oceania expresses any opinion that does not coincide with the one that the government has. Such an opinion is usually a political one, such as saying that the country is changing the past, or lying to its citizens. The reason why "Thought Crime" exists, is so that people will be afraid to question the government, and will accept everything that they say.One way that the protagonist, Winston, commits "Thought Crime" is by writing in his journal. In his journal, he writes about how he remembers Oceania being allied with Eastasia before allying with Eurasia. Although, the change in ally was never announced to the public. The mere fact that Winston remembers it, and states in his journal that it occurred, is enough to entail his death, because of committing "Thought Crime." Winston commits "Thought Crime" because the journal in which he writes, is his therapeutic way of preventing his sanity from eroding away.
Montag, from "Fahrenheit 451," committs the illegal act of reading a book. This is considered illegal because reading is banned. It's banned because a book is considered an object that possess a threat to the society's idealistic concept of making everyone equal. That's because if one reads more than other people, then they will become more intelligent, and they will know far more than the everyone else. But in this society, intellectual people are looked upon as people that make everyone else feel inferior, therefore, the only way to stop such feelings of inferiority from occuring is by taking their only source of information away--books. The reason why Montag committs the illegal act of reading is because of his search for his inner saddness, and emptiness. He only becomes aware of these emotions when an intellectual girl, Clarisse, asks him if he's happy.
In "The Handmaid's Tale", one act that Offred commits which is not permitted, is reading. This act takes place in the Commander's office, as he offers her several magazines to read (one magazine per every session). The reason why, women are not given access to reading, is so that female literacy will cease to exist. That's because in the theorocratic government of Gilead, knowledge is a temptation, and temptation could lead to sinning. Therefore, by taking away the source of knowledge, (books and magazines) the chance that women will sin is also greately reduced. In addition to that, causing female illiteracy to spread throughout the female population like a disease, will also ensure that the females will remain under control. After all, knowledge is power; and when no knowledge exists, neither does power.
The acts of breaking the law that are most connected, are the ones in "The Handmaid's Tale" and "Fahrenheit 451." Both of these acts involve reading as the breaking of the law, because by not reading, people are kept under complete control. In "1984," the law that is broken by Winston, "Thought Crime," is far more strict and harder not to break. That is because not committing "Thought Crime" requires one to fight against their own instincts, and to keep them in their subconscious in order to make sure that they are not expressed. What the party gains from this is complete power. In fact, by imposing the rules onto the characters, the government from all three novels gain power. This power enables them to shape the society however they wish.
One commonality that exists between the three novels, is a law that gets broken by each protagonist.
In "1984," the law that Winston breaks is referred to as "Thought Crime." The way that "Thought Crime," is committed, is when a citizen of Oceania expresses any opinion that does not coincide with the one that the government has. Such an opinion is usually a political one, such as saying that the country is changing the past, or lying to its citizens. The reason why "Thought Crime" exists, is so that people will be afraid to question the government, and will accept everything that they say.One way that the protagonist, Winston, commits "Thought Crime" is by writing in his journal. In his journal, he writes about how he remembers Oceania being allied with Eastasia before allying with Eurasia. Although, the change in ally was never announced to the public. The mere fact that Winston remembers it, and states in his journal that it occurred, is enough to entail his death, because of committing "Thought Crime." Winston commits "Thought Crime" because the journal in which he writes, is his therapeutic way of preventing his sanity from eroding away.
Montag, from "Fahrenheit 451," committs the illegal act of reading a book. This is considered illegal because reading is banned. It's banned because a book is considered an object that possess a threat to the society's idealistic concept of making everyone equal. That's because if one reads more than other people, then they will become more intelligent, and they will know far more than the everyone else. But in this society, intellectual people are looked upon as people that make everyone else feel inferior, therefore, the only way to stop such feelings of inferiority from occuring is by taking their only source of information away--books. The reason why Montag committs the illegal act of reading is because of his search for his inner saddness, and emptiness. He only becomes aware of these emotions when an intellectual girl, Clarisse, asks him if he's happy.
In "The Handmaid's Tale", one act that Offred commits which is not permitted, is reading. This act takes place in the Commander's office, as he offers her several magazines to read (one magazine per every session). The reason why, women are not given access to reading, is so that female literacy will cease to exist. That's because in the theorocratic government of Gilead, knowledge is a temptation, and temptation could lead to sinning. Therefore, by taking away the source of knowledge, (books and magazines) the chance that women will sin is also greately reduced. In addition to that, causing female illiteracy to spread throughout the female population like a disease, will also ensure that the females will remain under control. After all, knowledge is power; and when no knowledge exists, neither does power.
The acts of breaking the law that are most connected, are the ones in "The Handmaid's Tale" and "Fahrenheit 451." Both of these acts involve reading as the breaking of the law, because by not reading, people are kept under complete control. In "1984," the law that is broken by Winston, "Thought Crime," is far more strict and harder not to break. That is because not committing "Thought Crime" requires one to fight against their own instincts, and to keep them in their subconscious in order to make sure that they are not expressed. What the party gains from this is complete power. In fact, by imposing the rules onto the characters, the government from all three novels gain power. This power enables them to shape the society however they wish.
The Handmaid's tale: Ignorance is bliss (Application)
Margaret Atwood, The Handmaid's Tale. pages 100-200
"What could she have been thinking about? Not much, I guess; not back then, not at the time. She was thinking about how not to think. The times were abnormal. She took pride in her appearance. She did not believe he was a monster. He was not a monster, to her. Probably he had some endearing trait: he whistled, off key, in the shower, he had a yen for truffles, he called his dog Liebchen and made it sit up for little pieces of raw steak...All this she would have believed, because otherwise how would she go on living?" (Atwood 138)
In this quote, the protagonist, Ofglen reflects on a documentary that she saw when she was young.
This quote was chosen because its relevance in regards to the "ignorance is bliss" proverb. The concept in the quote shows how the "ignorance is bliss" proverb applies to a situation, such as the one in the novel.
The cliché "Ignorance is Bliss" saying, expresses the fact that in order for one to live in a state of bliss, one must learn to ignore, or block out certain truths that would otherwise awaken them from their reverie. The truths that they must block out is what are known as ugly truths; truths that can shatter their idealistic image of a person or a situation.
In the case of the woman portrayed in this quote, she must ignore the fact that her boyfriend works for one of the camps where the Jews are held prior to being killed. By ignoring this major detail from her boyfriend's life, she focuses on other positive characteristics which he possesses. Characteristics that she finds adorable, such as the way he whistles in the shower, or plays around with his dog, or simply the fact that he's nice to her. This is merely a technique that she uses in order to detract her attention, and therefore, be capable of continuing to live. The reason why she focuses on the positive aspects, is because the only way that one will feel like life is worth living, is if they feel like there's something worth living for. And in her case, she is making herself believe that their relationship is something that is worth being alive for.
"What could she have been thinking about? Not much, I guess; not back then, not at the time. She was thinking about how not to think. The times were abnormal. She took pride in her appearance. She did not believe he was a monster. He was not a monster, to her. Probably he had some endearing trait: he whistled, off key, in the shower, he had a yen for truffles, he called his dog Liebchen and made it sit up for little pieces of raw steak...All this she would have believed, because otherwise how would she go on living?" (Atwood 138)
In this quote, the protagonist, Ofglen reflects on a documentary that she saw when she was young.
This quote was chosen because its relevance in regards to the "ignorance is bliss" proverb. The concept in the quote shows how the "ignorance is bliss" proverb applies to a situation, such as the one in the novel.
The cliché "Ignorance is Bliss" saying, expresses the fact that in order for one to live in a state of bliss, one must learn to ignore, or block out certain truths that would otherwise awaken them from their reverie. The truths that they must block out is what are known as ugly truths; truths that can shatter their idealistic image of a person or a situation.
In the case of the woman portrayed in this quote, she must ignore the fact that her boyfriend works for one of the camps where the Jews are held prior to being killed. By ignoring this major detail from her boyfriend's life, she focuses on other positive characteristics which he possesses. Characteristics that she finds adorable, such as the way he whistles in the shower, or plays around with his dog, or simply the fact that he's nice to her. This is merely a technique that she uses in order to detract her attention, and therefore, be capable of continuing to live. The reason why she focuses on the positive aspects, is because the only way that one will feel like life is worth living, is if they feel like there's something worth living for. And in her case, she is making herself believe that their relationship is something that is worth being alive for.
Saturday, December 13, 2008
The Handmaid's tale: Opening up (Analysis)
Margaret Atwood, The Handmaid's Tale. pages 3-100.
"The tulips along the border are redder than ever, opening, no longer wine cups but chalices; thrusting themselves they are old they turn themselves inside out, then explode slowly, the petals thrown out like shards." (Atwood 43)
Offred observes the petals of the blooming tulips as she is walking past the garden and heading inside the home.
The reason why this quote was chosen is because of it's hidden complexity. It's a quote that appears insignificant upon first sight, but when read the second time one finds a link between the situation that Ofglen is trapped in and the opening of the tulip's petals.
The red tulip reflects the emotions that Offred is experiencing. Its red colour symbolizes the strong longing to bond with someone that Offred is feeling. It is an impulse that emerges as a result of the lack of human connection that she has. This is because in the republic of Gilead, having a friendship with someone is viewed as taking a risk, since friendships are looked upon as being suspicious. Furthermore, the red tullips being "redder than ever" also symbolizes the sexual impulse that she is feeling, an impulse that is stronger than ever. This sexual impulse originates from her wanting to have a human connection with someone. A physical or emotional connection.
Furthermore, the fact that the tulips are opening up more than before, reflects the fact that she is reaching out for a way to full fill these impulses more than she has before. This shows how just like it's in a tulip's nature to open up and flourish due to the fact that it's a flower; it's also in Offred's nature to reach for ways to fulfill her need for physical and emotional love because she's human . Furthermore, Offred accentuates the fact that the same way that a tulip's petals are thrown out like shards when the flower withers away,or in other words; the same way that it's in a flower's nature to have its petals fall off once it opens up and withers away, its also inevitable that Offred will cease to exist if she continues to reach out for these things.
The main message that Atwood highlights through this excerpt from the novel is that humans are just as fragile as flowers when it comes to love. That's because they reach out for love, long for love, and they open themselves up and they make themselves vulnerable, just like flowers. But in the end,the same way that its inevitable that a flower will wither away, its also inevitable that a relationship will end (most often).
"The tulips along the border are redder than ever, opening, no longer wine cups but chalices; thrusting themselves they are old they turn themselves inside out, then explode slowly, the petals thrown out like shards." (Atwood 43)
Offred observes the petals of the blooming tulips as she is walking past the garden and heading inside the home.
The reason why this quote was chosen is because of it's hidden complexity. It's a quote that appears insignificant upon first sight, but when read the second time one finds a link between the situation that Ofglen is trapped in and the opening of the tulip's petals.
The red tulip reflects the emotions that Offred is experiencing. Its red colour symbolizes the strong longing to bond with someone that Offred is feeling. It is an impulse that emerges as a result of the lack of human connection that she has. This is because in the republic of Gilead, having a friendship with someone is viewed as taking a risk, since friendships are looked upon as being suspicious. Furthermore, the red tullips being "redder than ever" also symbolizes the sexual impulse that she is feeling, an impulse that is stronger than ever. This sexual impulse originates from her wanting to have a human connection with someone. A physical or emotional connection.
Furthermore, the fact that the tulips are opening up more than before, reflects the fact that she is reaching out for a way to full fill these impulses more than she has before. This shows how just like it's in a tulip's nature to open up and flourish due to the fact that it's a flower; it's also in Offred's nature to reach for ways to fulfill her need for physical and emotional love because she's human . Furthermore, Offred accentuates the fact that the same way that a tulip's petals are thrown out like shards when the flower withers away,or in other words; the same way that it's in a flower's nature to have its petals fall off once it opens up and withers away, its also inevitable that Offred will cease to exist if she continues to reach out for these things.
The main message that Atwood highlights through this excerpt from the novel is that humans are just as fragile as flowers when it comes to love. That's because they reach out for love, long for love, and they open themselves up and they make themselves vulnerable, just like flowers. But in the end,the same way that its inevitable that a flower will wither away, its also inevitable that a relationship will end (most often).
The Handmaid's tale: Aspects of Freedom (Analysis)
Margaret Atwood,The Handmaid's Tale. pages 7-100
"There is more than one kind of freedom.Freedom to and freedom from. In the days of anarchy, it was freedom to. Now you are being given freedom from. Don't underrate it." (Atwood 24)
This quote was chosen because it conveys the contrast between the type of freedom that exists before the republic of Gilead, and after.
Aunt Lydia says this while reminiscing on what the world is like before the republic of Gilead comes to life. The previous society is one that is filled with freedom because there are no set rules, and no set limits. Therefore, the women in that society have the "freedom to" do whatever they wish. They have the ability to earn their own money, wear whatever they wish,and do whatever they wish. But such a freedom has its disadvantages as well. These disadvantages include the fact that women are not protected, and they have to avoid doing certain things in order to be as safe as possible. Things such as not opening their door to a stranger, and not going anywhere alone at night.
But in the days of the republic of Gilead, women no longer have to endure these things because they are granted the "freedom from" them. They are granted such a freedom through the strict regime of the republic of Gilead, where every Handmaid is responsible for giving birth to a child. While responsible for such as "accomplishment" the Handmaid's have their "freedom to" do what they wish taken away from them. In addition to that, they are also responsible for certain duties such as going to the shop to bring certain goods, taking part in "The Ceremony," and following the rules of the household that they reside in.
These two freedoms are represented as freedoms that cannot co-exist. That is because when one is granted one freedom, the other is immediately snatched away. Through this example Atwood is showing how the society that one resides in today would be shaped if one would be granted freedom from all the crimes that occur in this world, crimes such as being raped. She is showing that such crimes can only cease if the government would adapt a strict regime like the one in Gilead, where people would submit to a larger group that would protect them from any threats.
"There is more than one kind of freedom.Freedom to and freedom from. In the days of anarchy, it was freedom to. Now you are being given freedom from. Don't underrate it." (Atwood 24)
This quote was chosen because it conveys the contrast between the type of freedom that exists before the republic of Gilead, and after.
Aunt Lydia says this while reminiscing on what the world is like before the republic of Gilead comes to life. The previous society is one that is filled with freedom because there are no set rules, and no set limits. Therefore, the women in that society have the "freedom to" do whatever they wish. They have the ability to earn their own money, wear whatever they wish,and do whatever they wish. But such a freedom has its disadvantages as well. These disadvantages include the fact that women are not protected, and they have to avoid doing certain things in order to be as safe as possible. Things such as not opening their door to a stranger, and not going anywhere alone at night.
But in the days of the republic of Gilead, women no longer have to endure these things because they are granted the "freedom from" them. They are granted such a freedom through the strict regime of the republic of Gilead, where every Handmaid is responsible for giving birth to a child. While responsible for such as "accomplishment" the Handmaid's have their "freedom to" do what they wish taken away from them. In addition to that, they are also responsible for certain duties such as going to the shop to bring certain goods, taking part in "The Ceremony," and following the rules of the household that they reside in.
These two freedoms are represented as freedoms that cannot co-exist. That is because when one is granted one freedom, the other is immediately snatched away. Through this example Atwood is showing how the society that one resides in today would be shaped if one would be granted freedom from all the crimes that occur in this world, crimes such as being raped. She is showing that such crimes can only cease if the government would adapt a strict regime like the one in Gilead, where people would submit to a larger group that would protect them from any threats.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)